| Platinum | The Original Graziano's Pizza Restaurant |
| Gold | Portobello Pizza |
| Silver | My N.Y. Pizza |
| Bronze | The Curry Pizza Company |
| Top Pick | 5 Star Pizza & Wings |
| Top Pick | Domino's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Fontana Pizza Co. |
| Top Pick | Porky's |
| Top Pick | Shakey's Pizza Parlor |